I'm making brony treat bags for the brony meetup I'm hosting Oct 23rd. So far I have:
Clear treat bags with a haunted house/tree printed on them. The biggest I could find
Pixie Sticks - representing Pinkie Pie
Smarties - I plan on rolling pieces of paper around them to look like the scrolls Spike sends to Celestia. Possible "fortunes" or quotes?
Hershey's Special Dark kisses representing Nightmare Moon
Milky way bars representing Twilight Sparkle
Skittles for Rainbow Dash
Eyeball shaped bubbles for Derpy
Puzzle erasers I'll put something pony on (fluttershy?)
Star Crunches & make a Luna sticker to put on them
And my favorite..... Glue sticks (Krastos the glue maker)